Depression is sticky. And by that, I mean once you’ve experienced an episode, it’s more likely you’ll have another. And the more you have, the stronger the chance of recurrence.
It’s almost as if once you’ve seen it, you can’t “un-see” it, only more nuanced and complex than that.
I’ve written about why depression develops: the interaction between biology, genetics, environment and life experiences here; and the numerous options to manage it, including medication, psychological therapies, lifestyle interventions and other treatment options here.
In this article, I want to ponder how we might move forwards after trying “everything” and still feeling stuck.
It might sound like an oxymoron, but when we feel stuck, perhaps there’s room to also start living the life we want.
In other words, what if we stopped waiting to feel better before we started living differently?
While the concept might at first seem strange, it has the potential to give people struggling with low mood (as well as anxiety) a new way of looking at their situation.
It presents an interesting alternative to putting things off until tomorrow, which we all know is easy to do.
With depression, it’s normal to think there will never be a time when things might change for the better.
Any hope of doing the things we once wanted to do can be abandoned.
Everything seems hopeless.
And besides, what’s the point of even trying when perhaps nothing has worked before?
Carl Rogers, known for his person-centred approach to therapy, used the analogy of a potato in a darkened room; given a crack of light, it will find a way to grow.
It’s a metaphor full of hope, and Rogers likened it to his belief that people also have the desire to grow and maximise their potential.
Someone who is depressed but shows up to therapy has perhaps glimpsed a crack of light.
But the first obstacle is finding the energy to make changes because depression can zap it away.
How it feels to be depressed differs from person to person, but it’s often steeped in feelings of heaviness, lethargy and hopelessness.
It’s like being encased in a dark cloud, utterly isolated from the outside world, unable to see the point in life or feel equipped to change it.
I’ve experienced these feelings on and off in my own life.
You can find yourself going through everyday motions with a tangible pain rattling around inside that has no way out.
The thought of having so many things to be grateful for doesn’t help. In fact, it makes it worse because it highlights the idea that there’s something wrong with you. If those around you with similar or less can be happy, then surely there’s something wrong with me.
Friends with good intentions try to cheer you on, encouraging you to join them on nights out that surely would help you to feel better.
It’s lovely that they want to help, and sometimes it might, but it’s not that simple.
In fact, encouragement of this kind can sometimes make the isolation greater. It exacerbates feelings of “why am I like this?”.
Depression can rob you of any happy future thinking.
So back to the question: what if we stopped waiting to feel better before we started living differently?
Is that even possible given the lack of energy that depression brings?
For those really stuck in their depression, there’s a chance it could offer a way forward.
The concept is one that comes from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), an evidence-based approach developed by psychologist Steven Hayes and colleagues in the 1980s.
It’s not about resigning yourself to being depressed, but recognising that you can live alongside low mood while still engaging in things that you value.
I found myself in this place during my struggle with existential OCD. It took me months of CBT and exposure therapy to work on challenging and exposing myself to some extremely dark thoughts. This lessened the fear but didn’t eliminate the hopelessness and darkness I felt.
What did help was beginning to see that I could take a different path.
It wouldn’t be easy, but it was possible.
I needed to embrace the idea that I could work towards feeling lighter, enjoying relationships and activities I once loved, and living purposefully, even while I was struggling.
It took time, but I did find my way.
So what does the process entail?
At its core, ACT is about developing greater psychological flexibility: learning to respond differently to difficult thoughts and feelings rather than becoming caught up in them or trying to push them away.
It encourages us to recognise that we are not our thoughts, to make room for uncomfortable emotions and to focus on what truly matters to us.
By reconnecting with our values and taking small, meaningful steps towards them, we can begin to build a more fulfilling life, even when we’re struggling.
All of this may take time to understand and practise, sometimes with the support of an ACT-informed therapist.
I was lucky enough to find a therapist who walked alongside me as I navigated some very painful thoughts and negative beliefs.
Thought defusion
A key process in ACT is cognitive defusion, which involves learning to step back and observe our thoughts rather than becoming entangled with them.
Just because you think something bad about yourself or your life doesn’t make it a fact.
Engaging with these thoughts can make them feel more powerful and convincing, but we don’t have to believe everything our minds tell us or allow our thoughts to determine how we live.
You can read my article that helps explain this concept here.
Values and committed action
Either with a therapist or on your own, you can start to figure out what your core values are; not just what you like doing, but what feels purposeful. There are free resources on the internet to help you do this.
Once you’ve discovered or reconnected with your values, you can begin taking small steps towards incorporating them into your life, even when difficult emotions are present. In ACT, this is known as committed action.
The aim is not necessarily to feel better before making changes, but to build a more fulfilling life alongside whatever you’re struggling with.
It’s about not fighting the low mood but instead acknowledging it’s there and finding a way to keep life happening.
I remember cleaning the house sometimes during bad bouts of depression. At the time, I wasn’t familiar with ACT, but when the depression eased, I would feel good about the house being clean. Thinking back, I had already started my journey towards living alongside my value of, not so much having a clean house, but doing things and being productive.
While I didn’t stop noticing the depression, I did notice tiny shifts in mood and fulfilment. Instead of ruminating while lounging on the sofa, I was ruminating slightly less while cleaning the kitchen sink.
It’s a bit like reverse engineering. You focus on how you want to live, and by doing so, improvements in mood may start to follow.
It was only later that I learned about thought defusion and ways to engage less with negative thoughts. There are exercises that can help with this, which I’ll cover in a future essay.
Final thoughts
With all of this said, it’s important to acknowledge that what works for one person may not work for another.
ACT isn’t a panacea, and depression is a serious illness.
However, ACT offers a way of building a more fulfilling life without having to wait until we feel better.
By doing so, what may follow is a lifting of mood and a gradual loosening of the patterns that keep us stuck.
It helped me enormously, and research suggests it can help many others.
It brings to the table another thing to try, and in therapy, when you’re sitting opposite someone who is feeling hopeless, that’s a gift for both the therapist and the client.


